Three Gorges Probe

TabGroup

The Issue

Three Gorges Probe covers the social, environmental, scientific and economic impacts of big dams and other large-scale water projects in China, as well as alternatives to such schemes.

Launched in 1998, Three Gorges Probe is a bilingual website and electronic news service that provides uncensored coverage of the Three Gorges dam -- the world's biggest dam. Three Gorges Probe has broken major stories on the endemic corruption, human-rights abuses and technical flaws associated with the dam, and produced a detailed energy analysis showing the economic inefficiency of Three Gorges power.

We believe projects such as Three Gorges can be built only in the absence of good information about their real costs and benefits, and in the absence of an informed public debate and the rule of law.

History

Our involvement with the Three Gorges dam in China stretches back two decades. In 1989, Canadian engineers produced a feasibility study for the dam and recommended that the project "be carried out at an early date." Pro-dam members of the Chinese leadership then silenced debate within China about the wisdom of building the dam and pushed the project through the National People's Congress in 1992.

Probe used Canada's Access to Information laws to obtain the feasibility study, and organized and published a scathing peer reviewed critique of it by internationally respected experts in Damming the Three Gorges: What Dam Builders Don't Want You to Know (Probe International / Earthscan Publications, 1990 and 1993).

Probe subsequently published English translations of two collections of essays on the Three Gorges project written by eminent Chinese scholars, compiled by crusading journalist Dai Qing, and banned in China: Yangtze! Yangtze! (Probe International / Earthscan Publications, 1994) and The River Dragon Has Come! (M. E. Sharpe, 1998). These books have become seminal texts in the literature on the Three Gorges project.

Today, Three Gorges Probe has expanded its coverage to include all big dams and large-scale water projects in China, the restructuring of China's power sector, appeals by China's scientific and environmental experts to scale back China's dam building in earthquake prone areas, first-hand accounts by citizens who bear the brunt of lost land and livelihoods and harsh repression, and the extraordinary coverage by China's intrepid and increasingly outspoken press who dare to print the truth rather than propaganda.
 
Editor (English): Grainne Ryder
Editor (Chinese): Mu Lan

Three Gorges Probe stories may be reproduced freely, although we do ask that you credit Three Gorges Probe and send us the relevant clippings or Web site addresses.

Three Gorges Probe welcomes submissions. To submit an article or for press comment, please e-mail PatriciaAdams@nextcity.com or fax 1-416-964-8239.

Three Gorges Probe is available in both English and Chinese.

To subscribe or unsubscribe to Three Gorges Probe news service, please fill out the form here.
 

TabGroup2

Latest News

Filter by keywordFilter by content source

An ordinary citizen probes Three Gorges Dam finances

Qian Gang*
02/06/2010

On January 26, Ren Xinghui (任星辉), a young Beijing resident, decided to stand up against China’s Ministry of Finance. Why? Because his request that income and expenditures for the Three Gorges dam project be made public in accord with China’s National Ordinance on Government Information Release was rejected by the Ministry.  read more »

Dams trigger stronger storms, study suggests

Anne Minard
02/04/2010

Researchers are sounding the alarm that dams—along with their reservoirs—might also trigger more frequent fierce storms that could be the dams' undoing.  read more »

Rule of law meets the Three Gorges dam

Patricia Adams
01/27/2010

Ren XingHui, a Beijing resident, has made headlines in the Chinese Internet press by using the country’s new disclosure law to request information about government funding of the Three Gorges dam.  read more »

View All News

TabGroup3

Sources

Filter by keywordFilter by content sourceFilter by type

FACTBOX: Hydro development along the upper Yangtze and tributaries

Fan Xiao
04/06/2009

   read more »

Integrated analysis of stress and regional seismicity by surface loading: a case study of the Zipingpu reservoir

12/01/2008

Probe International provides a partial translation of a Chinese geological case study of the Zipingpu reservoir authored by scientists from the government's China Earthquake Administration. The study concluded that the 320 million tonnes of water in the Zipingpu reservoir had “clearly affected local seismicity” in the region and that, "it is worthwhile to further study if the effect played a role in triggering the Wenchuan earthquake."  read more »

Study on methods of reservoir induced seismicity: prediction of the Three Gorges reservoir

WANG Qiuliang, YAO Yunsheng, XIA Jinwu, ZHU Wenjing, WANG Dun, LI Jinggang, ZHANG Lifen
10/12/2008

Based on the analysis of seismogeological background, the Three Gorges Reservoir area is divided into 31 units according to different combined conditions of induced earthquake, together with 8 influencing factors, to give the prediction on probability and magnitude of RIS by adopting statistical prediction model, fuzzy mathematics and gray system model as well as artificial neural network model respectively. The results show as follows: in 31 units, the slight differences exist in results among three predictive methods, especially distinction between mathematics statistics models and artificial neural network model, which is also quite coincident with past macroscopical analogical prediction. The results are not only in accord with the past researchers’ basically, but also confirm with each other better: (1)from dam site to Miaohe segment, due to its geologic background, superficial fracture dislocation type of RIS may be triggered mainly, and the maximum (ultimate) magnitude will not exceed 3.0; (2) it is possible to trigger 4.5-6.0 earthquake in three places, including limestone area of southern Badong, near reservoir segment of Longchuanhe limestone area and far from reservoir segment of Gaoqiao Fracture limestone area; (3) it’s quite likely that the certain activity of Gaoqiao Fracture trigger tectonic reservoir induced earthquake.  read more »

View All Sources

TabGroup4

Oral Histories

Absence of Justice

oralhistoryteaser2.jpg

On November 18, 2002, the government of Dachang Zhen (Great Prosperity Town) in Wushan County, Yangtze River, sent the following dispatch about the wharf and the house belonging to Lu Chengming, who was to be relocated:

In order to accomplish the task of properly resettling those who are being relocated from our village, and to ensure the total success of the clearance from the dam area, a number of county, town and village cadres have repeatedly been to Lu Chengming’s home in Xingsheng Cun (Abundant Village) to persuade him to see reason, but comrade Lu Chengming still refuses to be resettled...  read more »

Bright Sun City's Dark Intent

TGP_OH3.jpg

Since 1993, a year after the Three Gorges dam was approved by the National People’s Congress, two kinds of population resettlement in the Three Gorges area were officially sanctioned.2 Either the local government could take responsibility for relocating people in nearby areas, on higher slopes or “in areas that needed to be developed,” under a policy known as “resettlement with development,” or individuals destined to be displaced by the dam could arrange their own resettlement, outside of the reservoir area, known as “relocating oneself.”...  read more »

Lost Lives: The Plight of the Migrants

tgp_oh4_lost_new.jpg

The Three Gorges Project approved by the National Peoples’ Congress in 1992 included a policy to settle all affected people on higher ground in the area nearby. These people were categorized as those resettling locally, and included those who resettled higher up on the slopes above the Yangtze, those who relocated to work for a local enterprise, and those who looked for friends and relatives nearby who they could move in with...  read more »

View All Oral Histories


 

TabGroup5

Blogs

Filter by keyword

State policies leaving Chinese citizens out in the cold

While citizens across China are confronting some of the most severe winter weather in decades, they’re finding that holdover policies from the Maoist era are making the situation worse.  read more »

Video: China's Three Gorges dam in trouble

Report from Al Jazeera on rising costs of the Three Gorges dam.  read more »

The Three Gorges tax revolt

Chinese citizens are beginning to ask questions about the official estimates and management of the Three Gorges dam  read more »

View All Blog Entries

 

TabGroup7