Mekong Utility Watch

TabGroup

The Issue

While environmental concerns and high gas and coal prices should be driving investment in more energy efficiency measures, more renewables, and onsite cogeneration plants that reduce consumers’ electricity and heating/cooling costs, the region’s utilities are fast-tracking plans for more giant-scale dams, conventional thermal power plants, and high-risk nuclear plants.

Mekong utilities do this because they can externalize the high costs and risks associated with these schemes onto ratepayers, taxpayers, and rural communities. They are backed by Western development institutions such as the World Bank, International Finance Corporation, and Asian Development Bank, as well as national governments and state development banks with a penchant for big-money construction projects no matter their real costs.

It’s the wrong direction.

While technologies for saving and producing energy are advancing in leaps and bounds, Mekong utilities are mired in oldstyle central planning and cartel-like behavior that cannot deliver what today’s consumers need or want.

Lack of adequate power supply – and the financing to build power plants fast enough to keep up with demand – is widely perceived as the number one problem in the region’s power sector. We think competition, and the lack of it, is the bigger issue. Whether the problem is too little or too much supply, more competition (less aid and government subsidies) would vastly improve the marketplace and help the region’s fledgling regulators do their job.

Companies offering ways to save or produce energy should be allowed to compete fairly at honest prices, regardless of what technology they use, where they are, how big they are, or who owns them.

Mekong governments – like most governments – move half-heartedly toward opening the region’s electricity market to competition while busy jostling for international subsidies to favour this or that technology over others, supply expansion over efficient use, and big over the right scale for the job at hand.

Millions of rural people do not have access to electricity service. Those who do have service bear the high cost of an inefficient and highly centralized system.

We don’t pretend to know what kinds of electricity technologies and services would best meet customers’ needs in the Mekong region. But we are confident the way forward is a shift from monopoly supply expansion to more diverse and decentralized energy sources and markets.

TabGroup2

Latest News

Filter by keywordFilter by content source

When the Mekong runs dry

Brian McCartan
03/17/2010

Low water levels on the upper Mekong River have renewed criticism over hydropower dams China has erected on the waterway's upper reaches. Environmental groups and governments have pinned blame on China's inward-looking water management policies, although some experts say the real culprit is unusually severe drought conditions in southwestern China, northern Thailand and Laos.  read more »

Low level of Mekong raises concerns over water management

03/14/2010

The Mekong River, South-East Asia's longest waterway, is at its lowest level in 50 years, raising questions about who is to blame - mankind or Mother Nature - for the region's diminishing water supply. The 4,350-kilometre-long river originates in southern China and meanders through Laos and Thailand into Cambodia, where it feeds Tongle Sap Lake before reaching southern Vietnam and emptying into the South China Sea.  read more »

Chinese dams blamed for Mekong’s dwindling flows and fish stocks

Jonathan Manthorpe
03/14/2010

Something is wrong with the mighty Mekong River, which frames the lives of 250 million people in six countries of Southeast Asia through which it flows and on which 60 million people depend directly for their livelihoods.

But there are widely differing views on why the Mekong has shrunk to its lowest levels in 20 years, with only half its normal volume in some places, so that vital fish migrations have been disturbed and river shipping had to be halted.  read more »

 View All News

TabGroup3

Sources

Filter by keywordFilter by content sourceFilter by type

Powering 21st Century Cambodia with Decentralized Generation: A Primer for Rethinking Cambodia's Electricity Future

Grainne Ryder
10/28/2009

This report by Probe International challenges the assumption that large-scale power imports and large-scale hydro dams are the cleanest and most efficient way to bring electricity to more people. We argue that recent technological advances have made it more economical and reliable to generate power on a much smaller scale, closer to where power is needed, using many smaller power plants and building-scale generating technologies. The global power industry calls this distributed or decentralized generation and it is what's reinventing the electricity business world-wide, rendering further investment in last century's giant-scale power plants obsolete
   read more »

The First Mekong Energy and Ecology Network (MEE-Net) training workshop - source materials

05/11/2009

Find here all powerpoint presentation files used at the first ever MEE-Net training workshop that took place in Thailand from 11 May to 30 May 2009. As Probe International's Policy Director, Grainne Ryder traveled to Thailand in order to take part in this historic exercise in cross-cultural learning.  read more »

Reclaiming the Sesan River

Grainne Ryder
11/15/2008

Ever since Electricity of Vietnam (EVN) began damming the Sesan River for hydropower, affected communities in downstream Cambodia have grappled with the question: what, if anything, can be done to reduce the worst effects of EVN dam operations?  read more »

View All Sources

TabGroup4

Blogs

Filter by keyword

View All Blog Entries

TabGroup5

TabGroup6

TabGroup7